::)Which boat is best for 23st on open water or all round
D8 without a doubt - you'll struggle in a Baggy at 23st. The D8 may be a little slower on the plane but in light airs/weight carrying/survival sailing it's the quicker/more manageable boat.
Where are you sailing?
Tim
if it is the d8 on the 2nd hand list it looks well priced and I would advise you buy before someone else does! [i dont know the seller].
John